Yoghurt Bacteria: Which One for What? A Pharmacist's Guide to 9 Super Gut Yoghurts

Woman in a bright kitchen holding a jar of homemade yoghurt, wondering which bacteria to use, with colourful 3D bacteria and question marks floating around her head

Over the past years I have made well over 140 litres of L. reuteri yoghurt. Somewhere along the way, friends started asking me the same question: "Which one should I make?"

Fair question. Dr. William Davis describes nine different yoghurts in his book Super Gut. But the benefits are spread over recipe pages, appendices and side remarks. So I put them on one page.

Not every yoghurt does the same thing.

Why these yoghurts are different

A supermarket yoghurt is fermented for about four hours with two standard bacteria. Davis does something else: one specific strain, 36 hours of fermentation, and prebiotic fibre to feed the bacteria.

The result is a different league. Davis had a batch of his L. reuteri yoghurt counted in a lab: 262 billion bacteria per half cup. Most of the lactose is converted to lactic acid along the way, which is why the yoghurt tastes tart.

And because each strain does something different, you choose the yoghurt by the effect you are looking for. Like ordering from a menu.

Now, mind you: the benefits below are Dr. Davis's statements, based on studies he cites. Where it says reported, it is the experience of his readers, not study results.

The nine Super Gut yoghurts

1. Lactobacillus reuteri (DSM 17938 + ATCC PTA 6475)

Davis calls it his "star yoghurt". Smoother and more moist skin, more collagen (fewer wrinkles), faster healing and more youthful muscle. It raises oxytocin, the bonding hormone, which goes with more empathy. It colonises the upper gut and makes its own antibacterial substances (bacteriocins), which helps prevent SIBO from coming back. It also keeps H. pylori in check.

Starter: BioGaia Gastrus (10 tablets, crushed) or Osfortis (1 capsule). Temperature: 37.7 °C, 36 hours. Fibre: inulin or raw potato starch.

Pregnant? Then only as a mixed culture (number 8) – because of the oxytocin.

2. Bacillus coagulans (GBI-30,6086)

Less inflammation and arthritis pain, fewer irritable bowel symptoms, faster muscle recovery after exercise. Milder and less tart than L. reuteri – many people find it the tastiest of all.

Starter: Digestive Advantage (Schiff), 1 capsule. Temperature: 46–50 °C, 36 hours. Fibre: inulin or raw potato starch.

3. Lactobacillus gasseri (BNR17)

About 2.5 cm less waist in 90 days, without changing diet or exercise. Fewer irritable bowel symptoms and less oxalate in blood and urine (relevant for kidney stones). A strong bacteriocin producer, so it also helps against SIBO recurrence. Reported: more strength.

Starter: Biothin Probiotic (Mercola), 1 capsule. Temperature: 43 °C, 36 hours. Fibre: sugar or raw potato starch.

4. Lactobacillus casei Shirota

Support against viral respiratory infections. In three trials, 100 billion bacteria per day halved the number of infections – and halved the duration when one did occur. That dose is far beyond what a bottle of Yakult provides, hence the yoghurt. Reported: a clearer head and deep sleep, especially together with L. reuteri.

Starter: Yakult, 1 bottle. Temperature: 43 °C, 36 hours. Fibre: inulin or raw potato starch.

5. Bifidobacterium infantis (EVC001)

A yoghurt for expecting mothers, who then pass the microbe on to their baby at birth and while breastfeeding. Babies with B. infantis have less colic, eczema and nappy rash, sleep better, and have a lower risk of asthma, type 1 diabetes and autoimmune disease later on.

Starter: Evivo, 1 sachet. Temperature: 38 °C, 36–40 hours. Fibre: sugar or raw potato starch – not inulin, B. infantis can't use it.

6. Lactobacillus helveticus + Bifidobacterium longum (R0052 + R0175)

Less anxiety, better mood; it can contribute to lifting a depression. Not everyone notices it, but those who do can notice it strongly. Reported (for B. longum BB536): relief from compulsive behaviour.

Starter: Mood Probiotic (Innovix Labs) or Florassist Mood Improve (Life Extension), 1 capsule. Temperature: 38 °C, 36–40 hours. Fibre: sugar or raw potato starch.

7. Super Gut SIBO yoghurt (L. reuteri + L. gasseri + B. coagulans)

Three strains that colonise the upper gut and make bacteriocins – aimed at SIBO, the hydrogen type and possibly the methane type. They are fermented together on purpose: that keeps L. gasseri in check, so the die-off reaction doesn't become too strong. Davis himself calls this experience preliminary.

Starter: 10 Gastrus tablets + 1 capsule BNR17 + 1 capsule GBI-30,6086. Temperature: 41.1 °C, 36 hours. Fibre: inulin or raw potato starch.

8. Mixed-culture L. reuteri

L. reuteri together with the two classic yoghurt bacteria (L. bulgaricus and S. thermophilus). The benefits of L. reuteri in a gentler form – for children and pregnant women. Mild, not tart; children like it.

Starter: 2 tablespoons of L. reuteri yoghurt + 2 tablespoons of plain yoghurt with live cultures. Temperature: 41 °C, 36 hours.

9. High-potency probiotic or kefir yoghurt

The effect of an expensive multi-strain probiotic at very high counts – multiplied for the price of one capsule or a few spoons of kefir.

Starter: 1 probiotic capsule (at least 2 billion bacteria) or 2 tablespoons of kefir. Temperature: 41 °C, 36 hours.

Other microbes Davis mentions

• Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG (Culturelle): recovery from diarrhoea after antibiotics, antifungal, helps suppress H. pylori. Works as a yoghurt too.

• Lactobacillus plantarum 299v: less bloating and abdominal discomfort in irritable bowel. Lives only in the colon, not the upper gut.

• L. reuteri NCIMB 30242: probably a valuable strain too, but not for the SIBO yoghurt – it makes no bacteriocin.

• Akkermansia muciniphila: protects the gut's mucus layer. It can't be made into yoghurt – it dies in air. You help it grow with green tea, blueberries, olive oil and prebiotic fibre.

• Saccharomyces boulardii (Florastor): a helpful yeast after antibiotic diarrhoea. As a yeast, not suitable for yoghurt.

Where to get the starters

Transparency: the shop links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I list the products Dr. Davis uses in Super Gut; where one isn't available, a clearly marked substitute.

For the nine yoghurts

• BioGaia Gastrus (L. reuteri; also for the SIBO yoghurt): Amazon

• BioGaia Osfortis (L. reuteri, alternative): iHerb

• Digestive Advantage (Schiff) (B. coagulans; also for the SIBO yoghurt): Amazon · iHerb

• Biothin Probiotic (Mercola) (L. gasseri; also for the SIBO yoghurt): Amazon

• Yakult (L. casei Shirota): Amazon

• Evivo (B. infantis): Amazon

• Mood Probiotic (Innovix Labs) (mood yoghurt): iHerb

• Florassist Mood Improve (Life Extension) (mood yoghurt, alternative): Amazon

• High-potency probiotic (yoghurt 9): Amazon

• Kefir grains (yoghurt 9): Amazon

Other microbes

• Culturelle (L. rhamnosus GG): Amazon

• Jarrow Ideal Bowel Support (L. plantarum 299v): Amazon

• Florassist Heart Health (Life Extension) (L. reuteri NCIMB 30242): Amazon

• LR Superfood Starter (L. reuteri SD 5865): Amazon

• Pendulum (Akkermansia muciniphila): Amazon

• Florastor (S. boulardii): Amazon

Fibre for the bacteria

• Inulin: Amazon

• Raw potato starch: Amazon

How to get the temperature right

Here is the part nobody tells you. The temperature matters more than most recipes suggest. L. reuteri thrives at body temperature and dies from about 43 °C. B. coagulans wants 46–50 °C. A few degrees off for 36 hours, and you grow something else than you intended.

And the temperature that counts is the one in the yoghurt. Once the milk sets, it stops circulating – and the middle of the jar runs cooler than the water around it. On my machines that difference was between 1 and 4 °C, depending on the culture and the room temperature.

That is why I calibrate the Culture Craft™ Yoghurt Machine with a reference thermometer in the middle jar, with real yoghurt, not water. The temperature you choose is the temperature your bacteria get.

Where to start

If you have never made one of these yoghurts: start with L. reuteri. It is the most researched, the most versatile, and the one I keep coming back to.

Then add what fits your situation – B. coagulans after hard training, L. gasseri for the waist, Shirota before the cold season.

One honest remark as a pharmacist: if you are seriously ill, severely immunocompromised, have a centraal veneuze katheter (CVK) or are pregnant, talk to your doctor before you start with high-count probiotics. That is not a formality.

Curious about the machine I built for exactly this? Join the waitlist for the Culture Craft™ Yoghurt Machine.

Let me know which yoghurt you start with.

Source: William Davis, MD, Super Gut (Hachette Go, 2022). Summary in my own words. This article is for information only and is not medical advice.

  • What is the difference between regular commercial yoghurt and a therapeutic 'super gut' yoghurt?

    From a clinical and pharmacological standpoint, the primary difference lies in the bacterial strains used, fermentation duration, and viable bacterial count (colony-forming units or CFUs).

    • Commercial Yoghurt: Typically fermented for only 4 to 8 hours using common starter cultures such as Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus. While beneficial for general digestion, most commercial varieties contain relatively low live bacterial counts by the time they reach consumers and may contain added sugars or stabilizers.
    • Super Gut Yoghurt: Formulated using evidence-based, clinically researched human strains (such as Limosilactobacillus reuteri or Lactobacillus gasseri) and fermented for extended periods (often 36 hours) at controlled temperatures. This prolonged fermentation, often supported by prebiotic fiber (like inulin), allows bacterial counts to multiply exponentially—frequently yielding over 200 to 300 billion CFUs per half-cup serving compared to roughly 1 to 5 billion in commercial products.

  • Which specific yoghurt bacteria should I choose for distinct health concerns?

    Probiotic benefits are highly strain-specific. As a healthcare provider, matching the right organism to your targeted physiological goal is essential:

    • For Mood, Skin, and Sleep Support: Limosilactobacillus reuteri (strains DSM 17938 and ATCC PTA 6475) has been shown to stimulate gut-brain signaling and promote the release of oxytocin, which can enhance skin collagen density, improve wound healing, and support deeper restorative sleep.
    • For Metabolic Health and Visceral Fat: Lactobacillus gasseri (such as strain BNR17 or SBT2055) has clinical data indicating support for waist circumference reduction, healthy metabolic regulation, and reduction of visceral fat accumulation.
    • For Small Intestinal Support and SIBO: Bacillus coagulans (e.g., GBI-30, 6086) produces antimicrobial bacteriocins and lactic acid that help suppress undesirable bacterial colonization in the small intestine while surviving stomach acid via endospore formation.
    • For Systemic Inflammation and Immune Balance: Bifidobacterium infantis and Bifidobacterium longum play a foundational role in restoring mucosal gut barrier integrity and reducing inflammatory endotoxins (lipopolysaccharides).

  • Why is 'strain specificity' critical when choosing starter cultures for yoghurt?

    In microbial pharmacotherapy, bacteria are classified by Genus, Species, and Strain (for example: Lactobacillus [genus] reuteri [species] ATCC PTA 6475 [strain]).

    Assuming all bacteria within a single species perform the same role is equivalent to assuming all members of the canine species perform the same function (e.g., a Chihuahua versus a Search-and-Rescue German Shepherd). Clinical traits are strain-dependent:

    • One strain of a species may produce specific antimicrobial peptides or upregulate systemic oxytocin, while a different strain of the identical species might have no measurable biological effect in those pathways.
    • When preparing therapeutic yoghurt, you must confirm that the starter culture or capsule specifically lists the alphanumeric strain code validated in clinical trials, rather than just the general species name.

  • Why do super yoghurts require a 36-hour fermentation at specific temperatures?

    The extended 36-hour fermentation cycle is designed to maximize the therapeutic bacterial population while accommodating the slower biological doubling time of human-derived commensal strains.

    • Doubling Times: Unlike industrial yoghurt bacteria, which multiply rapidly, therapeutic human strains such as L. reuteri replicate much more slowly (often requiring 2 to 3 hours per cell division). A standard 6-to-8-hour ferment yields relatively small quantities of these organisms.
    • Logarithmic Expansion: By 30 to 36 hours, bacterial colonies reach peak logarithmic growth, achieving bacterial densities hundreds of times higher than standard ferments before nutrients deplete.
    • Temperature Precision: Different species have specific thermal optimums. For example, L. reuteri thrives best around 100°F (37.7°C), whereas standard cultures often ferment hotter (around 110°F–115°F / 43°C–46°C). Fermenting too hot can kill delicate therapeutic strains, while fermenting too cool slows replication and increases the risk of contamination.

  • Can I use over-the-counter probiotic capsules as a starter for making super gut yoghurt?

    Yes, you can safely use select over-the-counter probiotic capsules as starter cultures, provided they meet strict criteria:

    • Verified Live Strain Identification: Ensure the capsule label explicitly states the exact strain designation (e.g., L. gasseri BNR17) and guarantees viable CFUs through the expiration date, not merely at the time of manufacture.
    • Single-Strain Isolation (Recommended): For therapeutic consistency, start with single-strain products or well-defined two-strain combinations. If a broad-spectrum capsule containing 15 different strains is used, faster-growing strains will quickly outcompete and suppress the slower, beneficial therapeutic strains.
    • Prebiotic Support: Probiotic powders require a sustained food source to thrive during extended ferments. Incorporating 1 to 2 tablespoons of an unflavored prebiotic fiber, such as food-grade inulin or unmodified potato starch, alongside full-fat milk or half-and-half, provides the necessary substrate for continuous bacterial expansion.

Related Post 

GrigoraMade with Grigora